Secret Society

Secret Society

Share this post

Secret Society
Secret Society
An Artist's Representation of a "Book Club."

An Artist's Representation of a "Book Club."

This is a SECRET SOCIETY

John Hodgman
Jun 03, 2024
∙ Paid
32

Share this post

Secret Society
Secret Society
An Artist's Representation of a "Book Club."
13
3
Share

Good evening, whenever you are. It’s me again: John Hodgman.

So I finished reading MIDDLEMARCH. I started it at the beginning of this year because our daughter was writing about it for college, and K had read it years before.

They both loved it. I felt a desire to honor their work, and I also wanted some spinach to eat to balance out the junk food of reddit I was gobbling up each night at 3AM. But it turned out, MIDDLEMARCH the most delicious, funny, insightful spinach there is.

Artist’s representation of a “book club”

My experience reading it was bookended by two serendipities of the kind we talk about here in SECRET sometimes: the false magic of coincidence that you find just by looking for it, but feels magical still.

The first is that, thanks to a SECRET SOCIETY member, I learned that my old friend Chris Frizzelle was just beginning a zoom book club on the subject of, of course, MIDDLEMARCH. I had only missed a maybe one or two meetings.

So I joined it, and I have talked about it but will say it again: IT WAS GREAT AND YOU SHOULD FOLLOW HIM.

Chris was the editor of The Stranger in Seattle for many years, and he is a great writer and teacher and book club leader. He does other things that I talk to him about in the conversation below, which is in the public area because I want you all to know him.

I would not have likely finished MIDDLEMARCH without all my book club friends on Saturdays. And week by week our meetings paced things out such that I arrived at the second serendipity: Our daughter finished writing about MIDDLEMARCH. And then she finished college. And then two days later, having driven her home in sad and happy silence, I finished MIDDLEMARCH.

The last few chapters really speed by. I read two of the final four in a coffee shop, with JULIET STEVENSON reading to me in my ear. Then I listened to her finish the book as I walked around Prospect Park.

The last sentence came as I reached the Citibike station near the farmer’s market. I won’t spoil it for you (though I think Chris and I do in our conversation; still you should watch it). Suffice to say I got stopped in tracks.

Me.

I stood there, probably for a full minute. MIDDLEMARCH is a big book. Other big things had happened. I tried to process all these conclusions that had arrived at the same time, but I couldn’t. So I bought strawberries and mustard greens instead. That was all I could do.

Later, we ate them. That was as good an ending as we got.

Anyway, this past Saturday was my first without MIDDLEMARCH book club, so on Friday I got greedy and made Chris Frizzelle talk to me about it and other things, just because I missed him.

And here it is…

Here is that link again for CHRISTOPHER FRIZZELLE and all his wordy enterprises.

Share

As you can tell, I shamelessly love reading aloud, and as I hinted to Chris, I was thinking it would be fun to read WUTHERING HEIGHTS to you.

Then I remembered that MICHAEL IAN BLACK already did this! And it was great and you should listen to him do it HERE. It’s funny how constantly I am stealing.

But I will still read WUTHERING HEIGHTS personally. (I won’t make Chris do it).

And up the stairs in the SECRET ROOM I am leaving something else for you. Maybe the dumbest thing I’ve ever done, but I had fun, so I do not apologize.

The rest of this message is secret…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 John Hodgman
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share